Flaine, a Brutalist ski resort designed by Marcel Breuer in the French Alps, was conceived in the 1960s by Éric and Sylvie Boissonnas to integrate modernist principles with winter sports. Despite its initial reception as unattractive, recent interest in Brutalism and modernist architecture is fostering a reevaluation of its historical significance. The renovated Totem Neige Hotel exemplifies this renewed appreciation. Flaine’s unique blend of architecture and art installations by renowned artists like Picasso and Vasarely highlights its potential as a modern ski destination that honors its innovative roots.
Flaine, often dubbed “the world’s ugliest ski resort,” stands as a significant example of Brutalist architecture. Conceived by wealthy French art lovers Éric and Sylvie Boissonnas, this resort represents a radical departure from traditional ski accommodations. Instead of cozy log cabins, the Boissonnas envisioned a bold, modernist experiment that combined art, architecture, and sport in an unprecedented way.
In the 1960s, Éric and Sylvie Boissonnas, fascinated by architecture and modern art, sought to create a ski resort that would stand as a testament to these passions. They selected a natural bowl in the Haute-Savoie region of the French Alps, with stunning views of Mont Blanc, as the site for their project. Despite local resistance from Savoyard farmers, the Boissonnas were determined to transform this location into a unique ski destination.
Laurent Chappis, known for his work at Courchevel, was initially brought in to design the resort. His philosophy emphasized harmony with the natural landscape, leading to the concept of “Fourth Generation” ski stations—self-contained settlements that minimized environmental impact. Chappis introduced the idea of “Snow Front” stays, allowing skiers to ski directly to their accommodations, which revolutionized ski resort design.
However, Chappis’s cautious approach clashed with Éric Boissonnas’s ambitious vision. Described by the local press as a “poet suffering from having 40 billion Francs,” Boissonnas was not one to compromise. In search of an architect who shared his modernist zeal, he turned to Marcel Breuer.
Marcel Breuer’s Vision
Marcel Breuer, a Hungarian-born architect and a disciple of Bauhaus founder Walter Gropius, was renowned for his work on projects like the Whitney Museum of American Art in New York and the UNESCO Palace in Paris. Breuer’s designs emphasized utility and modernism, free from traditional constraints. His architectural philosophy resonated with the Boissonnas’s vision for Flaine.
Breuer’s design for Flaine was a stark departure from traditional Alpine aesthetics. He used pre-cast concrete to create a series of buildings that blended with the surrounding rocks. The resort, intended to be car-free, featured structures with colors and shapes reflecting the natural landscape. Breuer believed that “architecture must be based on utility” and should “reflect a general and lasting quality.”
The resort’s construction began in 1961, with Breuer obsessing over every detail, from the sculptural fireplaces to the bent steel door handles designed to fit ski gloves. The design also included faceted slabs on the facades to catch the light bouncing off the balconies, adding an intricate crystalline pattern to the otherwise stark concrete.
The Opening and Initial Reception
Despite facing numerous challenges, including cost overruns and delays, Flaine opened in 1969. The resort boasted impressive amenities, such as Europe’s first artificial snow cannon, and a public art collection featuring works by Picasso, Victor Vasarely, Jean Dubuffet, and Carl Nesjar. The slopes were adorned with monumental art pieces, reinforcing the Boissonnas’ vision of Flaine as an open-air museum.
However, Flaine’s reception was mixed. Visitors accustomed to traditional Alpine cabins found the Brutalist concrete structures jarring. The resort’s modernist design, while groundbreaking, did not align with the cozy, nostalgic image of a ski holiday. As a result, Flaine struggled to attract visitors and fell into neglect.
Photographer Alastair Philip Wiper explored this dichotomy in his work, noting that while Flaine’s architecture is often derided, it represents a noble attempt to merge modernist principles with a ski resort. Wiper found that years of neglect had left the interiors of Breuer’s buildings in poor condition, far from their original four-star hotel status. However, he also observed unique architectural details, such as the chapel, door handles, and the dramatic Hotel le Flaine, which juts out over a cliff.
A Noble Failure
Wiper describes Flaine as a “noble failure.” While he admires Breuer’s ambitious vision, the resort’s execution fell short of creating a lasting, beloved destination. “Buildings should not be subject to fads, but reflect a general and lasting quality,” Breuer once said. However, Flaine’s architecture, nearly 50 years after its completion, is more often reviled than revered.
Despite the initial challenges, Flaine has witnessed a resurgence in interest. The Totem Neige Hotel, a refurbished Breuer building, has breathed new life into the resort. This renovation honors Breuer’s original vision and has sparked renewed interest in Flaine as a modernist landmark.
Interest in Brutalist architecture is undergoing a resurgence, leading to a reevaluation of Flaine’s significance. Wiper’s photo essay and the recent renovations highlight the potential for Flaine to become a unique, modern ski destination. By preserving Breuer’s vision and updating the resort’s facilities, Flaine can offer a blend of historical significance and contemporary appeal.
Legacy and Resurgence
As architectural tastes evolve, Flaine’s story reflects broader attitudes toward modernism. Initially celebrated for its innovative design, the resort fell out of favor as tastes shifted and concrete structures became symbols of failed urban planning. However, with the growing appreciation for Brutalism, Flaine is being recognized as an important part of this architectural movement’s legacy.
Wiper’s exploration and the recent renovations highlight the potential for Flaine to become a unique, modern ski destination. By preserving Breuer’s vision and updating the resort’s facilities, Flaine can offer a blend of historical significance and contemporary appeal. As the resort continues to evolve, it stands as a testament to the enduring relevance of modernist principles in architecture.
Flaine, once seen as a controversial and unattractive experiment, now has the opportunity to shine as a distinctive example of mid-century modernist architecture. Its transformation from a “noble failure” to a rejuvenated landmark demonstrates the enduring power of visionary design and the potential for renewed appreciation of Brutalist aesthetics in contemporary culture.
Quotes and Reflections
“What a wonderful site! How do we avoid spoiling it?” Marcel Breuer’s question in 1960 encapsulates the challenge and ambition of creating Flaine. This resort, with its controversial yet visionary design, offers a unique blend of art, architecture, and nature. As interest in Brutalism and modernist principles continues to grow, Flaine’s story serves as a reminder of the enduring impact of innovative design.
Gallery
