9 Best Toilet Seats of 2023 [Reviewed & Buyer’s Guide]

Toilet seats do not really expire, but changing them now and then can make the bathroom look a lot better.

There is no denying that the bathroom is an essential room in the house as most people start and end their day there. Not only does it have to have efficient bathroom ware, but it needs to be comfortable and relaxing too. This is why people tend to keep updating their bathroom accessories like taps, sinks, and showerheads.

However, why should toilet seats be left behind, right? The rise in demand for bathroom accessories has led to upgraded and uber-comfortable toilet seats too. Today we are here to review the 11 best toilet seats available in the market right now. 

So, without further ado, let’s get right to it!

Best Toilet Seats

Here is the list of the 9 best toilet seats to help you find the right fit for your needs.

1. Kohler 4636-7 – Best for Elegant Design

Plain white toilet seats are a thing of the past now. If you are looking to add some color to your bathroom, look at this Kohler toilet seat. Other than black, it is available in multiple colors like cashmere, almond, gray, etc., and adds a hint of elegance to the bathroom.

If you are one of those people who want to add a splash of color to the bathroom, these toilet seats are perfect. The Kohler 4636-7 is a black toilet seat with a glossy finish that will elevate the look of your bathroom. While this one is the elongated toilet seat, it is also available for round bowls.

We were particularly impressed with the quick-release hinges. These allow the seat to be removed quickly and conveniently. However, that does not mean it sits loosely on the toilet. The seat has grip-tight bumpers that firmly hold it in place. Both these features ensure that the seat stays put and only comes off when released using the hinges.

Additionally, the seat has a quiet-close feature and won’t come crashing down. This reduces noise as well as damage to the seat. Plus, all the hinges and hardware are in the same color as the seat, offering a seamless look.

Installation is relatively easy with this toilet seat, but the quick attach hardware seems to be where the problem lies. It is a bit flimsy and tends to loosen after prolonged use, so you will need to reattach it from time to time. Other than that, it is a great toilet seat for the house.

2. Mayfair 13EC 047 – Best for Comfort

Upgrading the look and feel of your toilet has been made easier thanks to the Mayfair 13EC toilet seat. Although this one is in black, it also comes in many other colors. Mayfair has been a leading name for many years, which shows in the high-quality seat it offers.

Comfort is a priority for many when it comes to toilet seats and for a good reason. No one wants to be sitting on an uncomfortable seat for even a minute, and toilet trips can be longer than that. This is why the Mayfair toilet seat is so popular; it has a wooden core for stability and a cushioned seat for comfort. 

The cushion is soft and well-padded. Plus, the seat is a bit on the heavier side, so you know it will stay in place. It is also pretty straightforward to install and has a twist cap hinge that easily removes the seat. Even cleaning it is effortless as you only need warm water and a cloth.

As we mentioned, it is available in multiple colors, but that’s not all. These colors are vibrant and don’t fade easily, so you can maintain the look of your bathroom for a long time.

Firstly, it is a bit expensive compared to its competitors. While this can be an issue for some, it does provide tremendous value in the long term. Secondly, the vinyl covering the seat tends to develop signs of cracks after some time, but these are minor and not very noticeable. 

3. Delta Faucet 811903-WH – Best for Durability

Next on the list is the elongated toilet seat by Delta Faucet. This is a reasonably standard toilet seat with no bells and whistles, ideal for people looking for just a sturdy toilet seat. It is made with high-quality plastic and offers everything that you will need. Let’s move on to the features, shall we?

Sometimes, it is not about the seat warmers or the cushions but just about having a seat that does the job right. This toilet seat by Delta Faucet is a no-fuss option that comfortably fits on any standard toilet and is available for elongated and round bowls. Since it is made with hard plastic, it is bound to be durable and sturdy.

You will appreciate that the seat has a slow-close lid, preventing damage and noise. Additionally, it has non-slip bumpers under the seat that keep it in place, making sure it does not shift around. Not just the seat, but even the lid is made of hard plastic so you can easily sit on it without worrying about damage.

Moreover, the seat is resistant to fading and staining. The plastic is high quality and so will not chip or peel either.

All in all, this is a great toilet seat to have if you are looking for something simple. However, it is important to note that the opening is a bit smaller than standard toilet seats, which can be a problem for some. For some users, the plastic bolts for installation broke quite easily. 

4. Bath Royale BR620-00

Next on the list is the Bath Royale premium toilet seat in white. The company is a small family-owned business that has slowly become a household name by supplying products to leading brands. All their products are made with high-quality materials that enhance the look and feel of the bathroom.

When it comes to bathroom seats, the last thing you want is for them to crack as soon as you sit on them. Plus, if you have a cabinet behind the toilet, standing on the seat to access it is the only reasonable option. This is why the Bath Royale seat is made with high-grade polypropylene that supports up to 400 lbs. 

Not only is it strong, but it is also long-lasting. The hardware of this toilet seat is made out of stainless steel that will not get damaged with prolonged use. Plus, the paint on the seat is fade, chip, and peel-resistant. Cleaning the seat is quite effortless, too, as it has a stain-resistant coating.

The seat also has a quick-release button that removes the seat so you can clean the bowl properly as well. Additionally, it is a slow-close seat so that it won’t slam, but it can also be pushed down for faster closing.

One of the most common complaints with this seat was that it scratches easily. Since the seat is made with polypropylene, it will not crack or break but it is not scratch-proof. It’s not a significant flaw, but you will have to be careful with belts and hard objects.

5. TOTO SS114#01

A toilet seat slamming is definitely one of the most annoying things to happen, especially when you’re half asleep. Not only is it loud, but there is a chance of hurting your fingers. TOTO has come out with a smart seat made to minimize injury and noise.

We were impressed to see that this seat by TOTO was made mainly to combat the issue of slamming toilet seats. This seat has an advanced hinge system that allows the lid to lower down quietly and slowly onto the seat. Additionally, even the seat has this soft-close feature, so in case both are up, they can both lower down slowly. 

TOTO does not compromise on the design, which is another impressive feature. The seat has a sleek and elegant design that seamlessly blends into any bathroom interior. It also has rubber pads underneath the seat to make it more stable and reduce any wiggling. 

It is also very easy to install since all the hardware is included. Plus, the bolts are top tightening, which reduces the need to bend down for too long to install it. Since TOTO has a range of products that are interchangeable, this seat is easy to remove if you plan to upgrade to a different one.

This seat is quite popular in most households for being sturdy and long-lasting. However, the white color of the seat tends to become yellow over prolonged use. But, this is not something you need to worry about for a good 2-3 years.

6. Topseat 6TSTE9999CP 000

One of the most crucial learning periods in a child’s life is when they are potty training. Not only is this crucial for the child, but parents too put in a lot of effort for this. Why spend extra money just to buy a spare toilet seat when you can have the 2-in-1 TinyHiney seat by Topseat.

Buying a separate toilet seat for your kid while they potty train can become a hassle to install. Most of the time, parents end up buying the ones that hook onto the side. The problem with that is that it moves around a lot. Thankfully, this issue has been resolved with this 2-in-1 seat which is for adults and kids.

The toddler seat attaches to the lid magnetically so that adults can use the full-size side without any problem. We also found it impressive that Topseat has included bumpers under the toddler seat to prevent pinched fingers. Moreover, it attaches firmly to the lid with no risk of falling down.

The seat is made out of wood and has a smooth finish for an elegant look. It even has metal chromed hinges that do not damage easily and keep the seat sturdy. 

This is a highly recommended seat by parents to anyone with young kids. However, the only issue is that it is not a soft close one which can be risky for the kids. Apart from the inconvenient slamming noise, fingers, and clothes can get stuck too.

7. Bemis 1500EC 390

This Bemis toilet seat is quite like the cushioned one by Mayfair, and there is a reason for that. Mayfair is part of Bemis, the parent company and primary manufacturer of high-quality toilet accessories. This Bemis toilet seat is the more affordable version yet retains style and elegance.

If you are looking for a brand that manufactures stylish and user-friendly toilet seats at an affordable cost, then Bemis is the one for you. This particular one is easy to install and even easier to remove. All the hardware is included and is made out of non-corrosive metal, which is guaranteed to last long.

This seat is ideal for residential use, which is why the installation is an easy process. It has a twist cap that locks the seat in place after the bolts have been tightened. All you need is a screwdriver and 10 mins in the day. But that’s not just it; the seat is made with enameled wood that makes it chip and scratch-resistant. 

Although this one is in white, it is available in multiple colors, allowing flexibility in the bathroom’s customization. The seat can fit any standard toilet and is available for both round and elongated bowls.

This Bemis toilet seat has glowing reviews, which is why it was difficult to fault it. However, some reviewers have mentioned that lighter-colored seats stain easily over prolonged use. Moreover, since the hinges are made of plastic, it tends to loosen over the years.

8. Ginsey 01581

Comfort does not have to come at a price, and the Ginsey toilet seat is proof of that. This padded seat is made to make long bathroom trips more comfortable and enjoyable. Plus, it is available in multiple colors so that it blends with the bathroom decor more seamlessly.

If cushioned toilet seats are your thing but you do not want to pay more than the market price of any average seat, take a look at this one. The Ginsey toilet seat in gray is ideal for any residential bathroom. It is oval and has a seamless construction that is sturdy and long-lasting. Plus, it is aesthetically pleasing. 

Not only is it available in multiple colors, but a few models also have patterns on them too. It is an excellent option for people that like out-of-the-box toilet seats. Additionally, cleaning is an effortless task. All you need is a warm cloth and soapy water to keep it free from any stains and dirt. 

The construction is durable since the nuts and bolts are made of metal. Moreover, it has protective bumpers under the seat that prevent it from slamming down too hard. It also helps reduce noise and pinched fingers.

You might be able to tell that this is the more affordable version of the cushioned Mayfair toilet seats. But since it is lower in the price range, it also lacks certain vital features like a slow closing lid. Moreover, it wiggles a bit every few weeks and needs to be tightened. 

9. J&V Textiles Round Toilet Seat

Finally, we have this incredibly stylish toilet seat by J&V Textiles. This one is ideal for people who like to see a bit of texture on their toilet seat. While this one is in black, they are available in multiple colors, and all of them have the same marble finish.

One of the reasons these toilet seats stood out for us was because of their look. It has a solid wooden make and the patterns on it make it stand out, no matter what kind of bathroom interiors you have. Other than looking good, the high-quality material also guarantees durability. It fits all standard toilets with round bowls.

The seat and lid are slow closing and hence do not slam down with a loud noise. Plus, the seat has plastic bumpers underneath it, creating enough space to reduce the chances of fingers getting in between. In addition, the bumpers also keep the seat stable despite prolonged use.

Even cleaning the seat is effortless as you do not have to spend hours on it. Just use a warm cloth with soap and water to wipe it down.

Since the nuts for installation are bigger and sharper than most others, a few users have had trouble tightening them from underneath. And although the vinyl covering is excellent, there are cases where it has developed air bubbles.

Best Toilet Seat Comparison Table

Buying Guide For The Best Toilet Seat

When it comes time to replace your toilet seat, you want to make sure you choose one that meets all your needs. With the variety of options available, it can be difficult to decide which toilet seat is best for you.

To help make the process easier, here are some key factors to consider when choosing the best toilet seat for your home.

Size

When buying a new toilet seat, you must choose one that is the right size and shape to fit your toilet.

To determine the size of the toilet seat you need, you should measure the width and length of the toilet bowl from side to side and from front to back. These measurements will help you to determine the size of the new toilet seat you need. 

The proper size of a toilet seat should be slightly larger than the bowl itself. This allows for easy installation and also ensures that the seat will not be too small once installed. Some toilet seats come in universal sizes, while others are designed specifically for certain toilet models. 

Shape

The shape of your toilet seat should be taken into account because it needs to fit properly with the shape of your toilet bowl. Toilet seats are available in both elongated and round shapes.

An elongated seat is best suited for an elongated toilet bowl, while a round seat is best suited for a round toilet bowl. If the shape of the toilet seat does not match the shape of the toilet bowl, then it will not fit properly and will be uncomfortable to use.

Additionally, it may cause gaps between the seat and the toilet bowl, which can be a health hazard. Therefore, you should take into account that the shape of the toilet seat matches the shape of your toilet bowl.

Installation

Now that you have figured out which shape is best suited for you, the next thing to consider is the installation. There are multiple reasons why the installation is a factor worth considering; however, two reasons are the most important. 

First off, no one likes to spend hours with multiple nuts and bolts to get the seat fixed. It is time-consuming and tedious. Secondly, bending down and installing the seat from under the bowl is not possible for many people.

Hence, the best thing to do is either look for a seat with a simple installation process or one with less hardware to deal with. In addition, many seats are installed from the top which makes the process a lot easier.

Aesthetic Appeal

Aesthetic appeal is also another factor to consider when choosing the best toilet seat. Toilet seats come in a variety of colors, and finishes.

Wooden toilet seats are a popular choice for their classic look and earthy tones while plastic toilet seats are available in a variety of colors and textures, making it easy to find the perfect model to match your bathroom decor.

Material

A toilet seat is an important part of a bathroom, and the material used for it is essential for both comfort and hygiene.

Polypropylene plastic is a common material used for toilet seats due to its low cost, durability, and easy cleaning. Enameled wood toilet seats are also popular not just for their attractive design but also for their ability to withstand moisture.

Plastic seats are affordable and easy to maintain, but may not be as comfortable as other materials. The right seat will depend on the specific needs of the user, but many people prefer the warmth of a wood toilet seat.

The material used to make the seat should be taken into consideration because it affects the aesthetics, comfort, and overall hygiene of the bathroom.

Are toilet seats easy to install?

Yes, toilet seats are generally easy to install. Most models come with all the necessary hardware and instructions for installation.

What is the maximum weight capacity of a toilet seat?

The maximum weight capacity of a toilet seat depends on the type of toilet seat and its construction. Generally, the maximum weight capacity for a standard toilet seat is more or less 300 pounds.

Are there any special maintenance requirements for toilet seats?

To keep your toilet seat in good condition, it is best to avoid cleaning it with abrasive materials. You should also wipe the seat down regularly with a damp cloth to avoid any buildup of dirt or grime.

Which brands have the best toilet seats?

Some popular brands that are known for producing quality toilet seats include Kohler, Mayfair, and Delta Faucet.

And there you have it, a detailed review of the 11 best toilet seats on the market right now. We know how important it is to have a comfortable and efficient toilet seat at a reasonable price. This is why we hope this review has been informative.

Before we leave, we would like to reiterate some of our personal favorites to make the buying process a bit easier. If comfort is the priority and you do not mind spending a bit more than usual, we recommend the Kohler 4636-7 or the Mayfair 13EC 047.

However, if you are looking for a no-fuss seat that does what it says, we recommend checking the Delta Faucet 811903-WH. It is a simple yet efficient and durable toilet seat that is ideal for any house. And on that note, we shall take your leave but will be back soon with more guides and reviews. 

Related Articles

12 Best Bidet Converter Kit | Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

10 Best Corner Toilets of 2023 for Small Bathrooms

7 Best Kohler Toilets Reviewed [All You Need to Know]

5 Best Wall-Mounted Toilet

Kohler vs American Standard [All You Need to Know]

Niagara Stealth Toilet Review [All You Need to Know]